SHOP
    • Filter
    Sort

    FILTER BY

    Price
    Brands
    Shipping Options

    American Cheeses

    We are pleased to offer this fine selection of American made cheeses. For best results, allow cheese to come to room temperature before eating.

    Domestic Cheese Pairing
    Domestic Cheese Pairing | $75
    All-American Picnic
    All-American Picnic | $95
    Ohio Cheese Pairing
    Ohio Cheese Pairing | $48 $40
    Smokin' Midwest Cheese Pairing
    Smokin' Midwest Cheese Pairing | $45
    Nettle Meadow Sappy Ewe Cheese
    Nettle Meadow Sappy Ewe Cheese | $14
    Capriole O'Banon Goat Cheese
    Capriole O'Banon Goat Cheese | $15
    Montchevre Plain Goat Cheese
    Montchevre Plain Goat Cheese | $6
    Montchevre Garlic and Herbs Goat Cheese
    Montchevre Garlic and Herbs Goat Cheese | $6
    Montchevre Lemon Goat Cheese
    SOLD OUT
    Montchevre Lemon Goat Cheese | $6
    Reny Picot Smoked Gouda
    Reny Picot Smoked Gouda | $12
    Laura Chenel Fresh Chévre
    Laura Chenel Fresh Chévre | $8
    Humboldt Fog
    Humboldt Fog | $22
    DLM Handmade Fresh Mozzarella
    DLM Handmade Fresh Mozzarella | $11
    Deer Creek The Rattlesnake Cheddar
    Deer Creek The Rattlesnake Cheddar | $12
    Herkimer New York Sharp Cheddar
    Herkimer New York Sharp Cheddar | $10
    Carr Valley Applewood Smoked Cheddar
    Carr Valley Applewood Smoked Cheddar | $14
    Carr Valley Cranberry Chipotle Cheddar
    Carr Valley Cranberry Chipotle Cheddar | $13
    Paint Valley Ohio-Shaped Cheddar Cheese
    SOLD OUT
    Paint Valley Ohio-Shaped Cheddar Cheese | $15 $11
    Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese
    Tillamook Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese | $9
    Tillamook Smoked Medium Cheddar Cheese
    Tillamook Smoked Medium Cheddar Cheese | $9
    Tillamook Sharp Cheddar
    Tillamook Sharp Cheddar | $11
    Widmer's Cheese Cellars 4 Year Aged Cheddar
    Widmer's Cheese Cellars 4 Year Aged Cheddar | $14
    Black Diamond Cheddar
    Black Diamond Cheddar | $16
    Carr Valley Glacier Blue
    Carr Valley Glacier Blue | $10